View Single Post
Old 02-19-2013, 12:16 PM   #16
sakumeikan
Dojo: Sakumeikan N.E. Aikkai .Newcastle upon Tyne.
Location: Newcastle upon Tyne
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 1,157
United Kingdom
Offline
Re: Aikido IP/IS: Advanced Expositions in Centripetal Force

Quote:
Dan Richards wrote: View Post
Mert, if you just showed me a video of that man doing aikido, I'd say he was around 2nd kyu. And the shihonage he does at 2:45 would fail him for even a 3th kyu test in a dojo with exacting standards.

I just watched a couple of videos - what little there is - with Mitsuteru Ueshiba (Waka-sensei).

I mean, honestly, these guys remind of old tribute bands who tour, with maybe one or two original members, under the guise and name of the original band. Or imagine the Beatles grandkids touring around as the Beatles.

Meanwhile, some real leading edge akidoka, like Tissier, who's getting his balls busted by the agreements between the French government and Aikikai, are hindered in their own development, and more importantly what they could give to others.

I mean - the average person in the park in China is doing taichi for free, and at a higher quality than the average aikidoist is - all while paying dues and pledging allegiance and loyalty.

Meanwhile, people open dojos with the blessings of Aikikai and set themselves up as McShoguns. And everyone's got their thumbs pressed down on the one below them. The top-down hierarchy is getting mighty weighty. And we can see it in a decline in quality as well as drawn-out, or even stalled, graduations.

The more people communicate, open up, and truly develop, the realization that the emperor has no clothes is going to dawn brightly. As we move forward into the next ten years or so, things are going to get interesting. And probably a lot more free and fun, too.
Dear Dan,
Tell me Dan , have you ever seen the Doshu /his Ukes? You say they remind you of an old tribute band. I consider this view is in bad taste.
As far as Mc Dojos are concerned /or Mc Shoguns you always get these types of things taking place all over.Do you think Doshu supports or promotes these places and people?
As far as France is concerned the politics of Aikido has been turbulent there for decades.I hardly think the current Doshu /Aikikai officials have sole responsibility for this.Are you saying that Mr Tissier is unable to transmit Aikido to the masses due to pressure from the Aikikai or what?
cheers, Joe.
  Reply With Quote