PDA

View Full Version : Aikido and body shape?


Please visit our sponsor:
 

AikiWeb Sponsored Links - Place your Aikido link here for only $10!


Topper1296
04-14-2003, 12:44 PM
I am new to the board (first post) and I will be taking my first Aikido class on May 5. It is a beginnings class that last 2 months. My question is: Is Aikido a good MA for a tall, lanky person? I am 6'5" and about 190lbs. I know that being tall and thin is disadvantage in Judo because of the high center of gravity and long arms and legs with less leverage, but is tall and thin a disadvantage in Aikido? or is an advantage or does it really matter in Aikido?

I have taken TKD in the past for several years and the long arms and legs came in handy, but I am wanting to try something different. Aikido caught my interest in the past, but I didn't live in a place that offered it until now.

Thanks in advance.

Paul Klembeck
04-14-2003, 01:27 PM
Overall neither an advantage or a disadvantage. However, you will find that your height makes some techniques easier for you and some techniques harder.

Paul

erikmenzel
04-14-2003, 03:46 PM
With some techniques being tall rocks, but with others it sucks bigtime.

Main trick is not to let that put you down and practise the hard techniques more often. If you are lucky one of the unlogical techniques for a tall person might even become one of your favorite techniques.

Paul Sanderson-Cimino
04-14-2003, 04:48 PM
As a sempai told me, some people have body shapes that make certain things bad, and certain things good, and others have different advantages and disadvantages. (I'm agreeing with the previous posters.)

That aside, I'd actually say that most aikidoka I know (myself included) are on the wiry side. (Not necessarily tall.) My current testing partner is more stocky, though, and it doesn't give him problems (in fact helping him with a few things, I imagine, and giving him more momentum); aikido works for most people.

acot
04-15-2003, 07:02 AM
Isn't Seagal Sensei like 6 foot 5 inches? It doesn't seem to make his Aikido less beautiful.

Ryan

aikidoc
04-15-2003, 09:18 AM
We have a black belt in our organization that is about 6'11". He does very well. He's hell to throw in a koshinage though. You really have to extend. He takes a great tobu ukemi (flying breakfall) though.

Larry Feldman
04-15-2003, 09:34 AM
6' 4", 185, been practicing for awhile. You may have to do some minor modification to your technique - hopefully your teacher can help.

As an aside I once went to a seminar with a 6th dan - who started his own organization. He was a very short man, even for a japanese. His 'personal' style, and what he taught really emphasized his height (or lack thereof). Obviuosly it was not very valuable to me, (never met the 6'11" guy).

What I try to tell the tall students I have is to use the 'up' motions in technique as much, if not more than the 'down' motions.

Bend your knees. Look for ways to 'stretch' uke out with your length - horizontal motion.

paw
04-15-2003, 09:59 AM
Isn't Seagal Sensei like 6 foot 5 inches? It doesn't seem to make his Aikido less beautiful.

But it does make a difference. Seagal said his height was the reason he focused so much on irimi nage, for example. He also said it was why he so rarely used koshi.

Regards,

Paul

Kung Fu Liane
04-15-2003, 03:26 PM
hello,

i'm small and i find thats fine for me, and i know tall people who say the same. personally i think its great that there is a mix in aikido of people of different heights, weights and strengths, because at least you'll find out if you're technique works on different people. there's nothing worse than practising with people who are the same size and strength as you all the time, then finding out you've been missing something and your technique won't work so well on someone bigger/smaller or stronger/weaker. plus you'll have an advantage if you have to do front breakfalls over a row of people :)

incidentally most of the tall martial artists i've met have been thai boxers; i think they do well because of the long legs :)

KaitlinCostello
04-16-2003, 06:52 PM
I personally don’t think that weight or height make a difference. Every body build has its inherent pro’s and con’s, and those little “points” that you have to fine tune. I personally am about the shortest person in our group, standing a hair over five-two, and for lack of a better word-pudgy;) I can still roll and break fall like and fly through the air like the devil when the situation calls for it. Granted I’m on my toes ( lit.) as uke because Nage is generally 5 + inches taller then me. I’m also one of the only two women in the T/R class, so there is the natural strength and center difference ( but that’s another thread for another day).

I would think as a taller person you would have to shorten your stride between you and your partner during some techniques. You’d have to stoop a bit for shorter Nages like me ;)

Overall I wouldn’t worry about the build issue, simply have fun training.

Regards,

Kaitlin

Anat Amitay
04-17-2003, 02:14 AM
Hi there,

I myself am not tall but we do have someone in the dojo who is 1.93 meters (I think it's about 6.5?). He is a black belt and I don't think his hieght had ever interfered with his training. usually for men, their natural strength comes more of a problem than anything else. Since useing it is so natural, they have a hard time learning how to stop :) .

You might have some problems in the begining since you are still not used to the techniques etc. But don't let it get you down. If your sensei is good, he will teach you to deal with situations (if he is good he will also let you frustrate over some cases, to let you teach yourself, your body, what is right for it :) ).

I say Aikido is good for everyone, as long as they want to learn it, since it is a MA that doesn't require any begining shape, size, strength...

Hope you enjoy your training and good luck!

Anat

happysod
04-17-2003, 04:03 AM
Never seen a particular problem with a practitioner's body shape (except if totally overweight), it's normally a large disparity between nage and uke that causes the problems in technique. This is the fun bit where you learn to adapt your technique to blend with your uke which is why I prefer practicing with as many different people in the dojo as I can, sometimes with comical/frustrating results...

Daniel Mills
04-17-2003, 04:58 AM
I'm 6'1", and not far off 400lbs, and have recently begun studying Aikido. Less than 10 hours of training under my (so far non-existant) belt, and the only problems I'm encountering are with my rolls, predominantly due to a far weaker left arm/shoulder than my right, rather than any hindrance due to my size or weight.

In fact, the only problems I actually seem to encounter are during warm-ups, where I can't stretch as much as the other people, because my stomach gets in the way :)

batemanb
04-17-2003, 05:59 AM
I'm 6'2" and about 180lbs, been practicing nearly 12 years. I agree with most of the above posters. i.e. some techniques work well, some not so. For me, the technique that I find hardest to do is koshinage (hip throw), and that's because my battered old knees (not from Aiki) don't work well when I sink down. Other than that, don't have too many problems with any of the other techniques (aside from lack of ability ;))

Sven Groot
04-17-2003, 06:19 AM
I may only be 5'10", but I do sometimes practice with people a good deal smaller than me, so for all intents and purposes I am tall in such situations. I find the difference in height does matter, but it is not necessarily a disadvantage. I may not be an advantage either. It's just... different.

In any case, you won't know until you try, and especially such an introductory course like the one you're going to take is very good for finding out if Aikido is something for you. I personally don't think you'll have any difficulties though, but then again, what do I know? :)

shadow
04-17-2003, 07:12 AM
im about your height, and as mentioned plenty of times above its great for some and worse for others of the techniques.

but us tall fellas have to use our legs.... koshinage on a small person is soooo painful sometimes hahaha.

sensei is always like "bend your legs not your back damien"

Greg Jennings
04-18-2003, 05:45 PM
I'm almost 6'3", 190 lbs. My height and build, like everything else, has been a trade-off.

Iriminage is easy for me. I have to work harder for shihonage with short uke.

Koshinage used to be hard for me. When I started doing it the standard Iwama way, it got much, much easier. Height isn't as much an issue.

Regards,

rachford
04-21-2003, 05:09 PM
I'm 6'3" & 215 lbs. My biggest problem is finding someone bigger to play with. Send me the 6'11" guy!

Women tend to be intimidated until ~1st Kye, then the seek you out and have fun giving you fast break-falls.

SeiserL
04-21-2003, 05:32 PM
6'4", 225 here. Some waza are made to give big ment the advantage. Others are a short man's Aikido. Learn to adapt.