View Single Post
Old 10-02-2001, 09:11 AM   #30
Scott_in_Kansas
Location: Kansas City, KS
Join Date: Aug 2001
Posts: 16
Offline
Thanks L.C.! I applaud your opinion. As far as the discussion on what is a traditional art, here is my opinion:

I consider the traditional arts to be karate, jujitsu, kung fu, aikido, jujitsu (stand up variety), judo, etc. I even consider Ed Parker's Kenpo a traditional art. They are arts which are taught in a dojo, have a code of conduct, uniforms. Proficiency is attained through years of training, perfection of technique and some physical conditioning.

I consider MMA to be things like combining boxing and wrestling and a few submissions. Heavy emphasis is placed on physical conditioning. Very little emphasis seems to be placed on perfection of technique (especially striking technique).

I consider Frank Shamrock to be the poster child for MMA. While I think he is a phenomenal athlete and competitor, I was amazed to find the at the time he won in the UFC, he had only been doing MMA for 4-5 years!!!! I surely thought a seasoned traditional artist could do better.

Respectfully,

Scott in Kansas
  Reply With Quote