AikiWeb Aikido Forums - View Single Post

Edward · 01-20-2002, 10:11 PM

So you mean that Senseis Saito, Kohei, Tamura, Chiba, Kurita...etc were never Uch-Deshi?

That's a very revolutionary information and would change Aikido history if proven true. Are you sure about it? I read Dr. Goldsbury's post and didn't find it convincing. Uchi_Deshi are the live-in students who perform various duties including carrying the bag of the founder and serving as his punching bags, so to speak. I don't believe that all the present day Shihans who were Uchi-Deshi to Osensei are all a bunch of LIARS.

As for the mentioned pre-war Uchi Deshi believing in Osensei powers, no one is disputing this with you, so you don't have to repeat it about 4 times

Cheers,
Edward

01-20-2002, 10:11 PM	#28
Edward Location: Bangkok Join Date: Oct 2001 Posts: 803 Offline	So you mean that Senseis Saito, Kohei, Tamura, Chiba, Kurita...etc were never Uch-Deshi? That's a very revolutionary information and would change Aikido history if proven true. Are you sure about it? I read Dr. Goldsbury's post and didn't find it convincing. Uchi_Deshi are the live-in students who perform various duties including carrying the bag of the founder and serving as his punching bags, so to speak. I don't believe that all the present day Shihans who were Uchi-Deshi to Osensei are all a bunch of LIARS. As for the mentioned pre-war Uchi Deshi believing in Osensei powers, no one is disputing this with you, so you don't have to repeat it about 4 times Cheers, Edward Last edited by Edward : 01-20-2002 at 10:21 PM.