Quote:
David Orange wrote:
I've been convinced that aiki is different from technique.
|
Of course aiki is different from technique.
Quote:
David Orange wrote:
The technique is jujutsu (as Mochizuki considered aikido to be). There's no surprise that some cognates of these techniques show up throughout every fighting art. Timing and techniques can be extremely effective.
But aiki is not "timing and technique"--even blending, non-resistant technique.
|
Ju is not technique either.
Quote:
David Orange wrote:
I'm convinced that aiki actually is a body skill independent from movement.
|
How would you describe it? What are its qualities? What distinguishes it from other skills?
Quote:
David Orange wrote:
"Aikido technique" is form.
Aiki is formless.
|
Agreed. Do you think the formless must always be manifested in form?
Quote:
David Orange wrote:
Interesting that, after all Dan Richards' explanations of what aiki, IP and IS are, after meeting Howard, he's thinking of going back to judo.
That is the meaning of "It has to be felt."
|
Unless you know something the rest of of don't, I think you might want to read the thread more carefully. Dan Richards started the thread. Richard Stevens is the guy who is thinking about going back to judo.