eh, not so different really...
No, this is very far off. Very BIG movements and incomplete spirals and...uke already initiating the fall or roll even before the nage has taken his balance. One of my 3rd Dan kohai (from another dojo) does that all the time and irritates the hell out of me. When I questioned him on his ukemi, he said, "what's the difference? The result is ending up on the mats anyway".