would you mind telling us which rules were broken?
Rule #3 and #4.
Niall comments on Ellis experience when he would have just post his and leave Ellis stuffs alone so readers can view each person view point. essential of rule #3: don't compare your experience with his or others, just post your direct experience
and rule #4, if you have disagreement, make another thread and post it there, which is this thread.
and most important, read the original post on "It Had to be Felt", the section on folks went into a fit about their teachers and so on.
aikido is about paying attention, yes? so pay attention to details.