oh hell no,
i'm in no way saying my sensei is wrong. I was just curious about the ways of aquireing rank and if sometimes people get rank and others wonder how they got it. I don't know enough to say someone should or shouldn't be a certain rank, i respect rank, you have to or your not going to last long in this world. It just sounded to me that sensei himself wondered if the said person should have aquired it. Is that a common feeling with teachers that get new students with rank?
Remember i'm as new as they come, i'm just curious.