Thread: Judo Koshi Nage
View Single Post
Old 07-12-2002, 12:15 PM   #10
Edward
Location: Bangkok
Join Date: Oct 2001
Posts: 803
Thailand
Offline
Quote:
Don_Modesto wrote:

1) See the link at "Jigoro Kano--Founder of Judo: Uki goshi" at http://209.15.75.68/judoinfo/video/video4.htm. It sure looks to me as if Mr. Kano is doing a textbook KOSHI.
Thanks for the interesting link. But I don't see your point. Pr. Kano is doing a standard Uki Goshi, which is executed with Nage and Uke having their feet and hips parallel, and a horizontal twist of Nage's hip in contrast to O Goshi (a frequently confused technique) where the hip movement is rather vertical. In fact O Goshi is closer to Koshi Nage than Uki Goshi, which was Pr. Kano's favorite technique by the way.

I have seen Uki Goshi taught at "some" aikido dojos under Koshi Nage appellation, but it is just an adaptation from Judo, just like Ippon Seoi Nage that some instructors like to use against a Yokomenuchi (we do use a variation of Kokyu Nage which looks very similar to Ippon seoi Nage but does not involve any Koshi).

But I might be wrong
  Reply With Quote