View Single Post
Old 01-04-2009, 06:55 PM   #100
dps
Join Date: Apr 2006
Posts: 2,133
Offline
Re: Effectiveness of Aikido in a combat situation

Quote:
Marlon Hester wrote: View Post
I am the author of this post, obviously, and I want to apologize to everyone who has participated in this discussion. I should have never given the title "Effectiveness of Aikido in a combat situation", because that is not what I was trying to get at. This has been discussed so many times. ]My real intention for this post was to get at why we train and dedicate so much of our lives to the Martial Arts.

Regardless I can see that enough people feel strongly enough that some of you have added more then a few responses to this thread and I think thats great. My intentions were to touch on the deep rooted reasons as to why we train.

Fighting is always associated with Martial Arts and so little of what we really do can be considered fighting in the practical sense. As a newbie I wanted to first define my thoughts of the difference between fighting and actual street lethal combat. Once we came to that common ground identify whether YOU ALL felt that training for street confrontations is a realistic goal that is achievable.

Then asking the question of those that have been in training for sometime if self-defense is not the goal then what is your real purpose for dedication to the art.

So with respect to all the senior teachers and students here who feel that I am rehashing an old topic, I will say that I only meant to take this issue further a long from the same old "Aikido is to soft" or "Aikido can't beat MMA" arguments.

Having said that I really do appreciate all your comments and perspectives. Once I get up and running with my own Aikido studies I would love sharing my ongoing development of self-discovery.
Quote:
Marlon Hester wrote: View Post
My real intention for this post was to get at why we train and dedicate so much of our lives to the Martial Arts.
I enjoy the physicality of practice, the satisfaction of doing the techniques effectively. I enjoy the sweating and the exhaustion. I enjoy the effect practice has on my state of mind and the coordination of mind and body. It is addictive and I want more.

Quote:
Marlon Hester wrote: View Post
Once we came to that common ground identify whether YOU ALL felt that training for street confrontations is a realistic goal that is achievable.
It is a realistic goal but there is no way to measure if it is achievable?

David