Quote:
Szczepan Janczuk wrote:
LOL
I was expecting this kind of excuse.
|
Your attitude doesn't leave much room for dialectics...
As I said, we have differing ideas about it.
Actually, I agree with you about a complete technique not opening for resistance. Still,
gotai, from a static position, needs to be trained. Otherwise we are unprepared for a moment when somebody actually gets to complete a grip.
And considerations of importance in
gotai solutions should be included also in
jutai execution of the technique.
I make it a point not to allow for big changes of the technique between
gotai and
jutai. Others be the judges of whether I actually accomplish it or not.
On the video in question, the henkawaza applications are done pretty much in the tempo I regard as reasonable for those techniques. They start from a gotai static position, still, but from then on move in regular speed.
Here's the video discussed:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eIvsCZE7xAw
I checked my other ikkyo videos on YouTube, but in each of them the techniques are done in an instructive slow tempo. Nonetheless, that's how I do ikkyo normally, although faster. No change of form.
Here's a bunch of them (although in slow-motion):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SrASNrLi7uI
Szczepan, by any chance, have you made a video that shows how it should be done, or have you seen other videos that meet with your demands?