Good points.
Imho there is no disconnect between effective Aikido that works in a "fight" and Aikido that attempts to connect, harmonize, engender peace etc. In fact I'd say that one would need the first to have the second in a world of people whose characters can range from angels to demons. Imho Ueshiba M. had no illusions about his desires to promote peace in the world, just like he had no illusions that he could kill a person if required at will. According to Rob, the principles should be applicable throughout.
It's interesting that one of the most peaceful martial artists I know is also someone who has taken life in a combative context, and he teaches Aikido. To me, part of the beauty of Aikido is being able to handle a myriad of adverse situations (including physical self defence) without losing ones connectedness to all things and ultimately ones humanity. To me, it is easy to give up one for the other, but you don't have to.
Quote:
|
We all have our sides. But, IMHO, nature has no opinions and takes no sides.
|
I like that
My 2 cents.