Re: Aliveness in Martial Arts Video Clip
very good point Ron!
That reason alone is why I have the following poster in our dojo.
"the winner of a hand to hand fight is the guy whose buddy shows up first with a gun".
Of course this is an Army thing....but I think it keeps things in the proper perspective.
I have been instructing basic combatives for about 4 hours a day all week to some visiting units. These guys have never done this stuff before.
I tell them that it is not really important that they learn how to do all the really technical stuff we are teaching them sweeps, various forms of guard, submissions etc....
What is important is that they train...and learn the basics and how to handle the stress of a combat situation. Really all they need to know is how to survive for a few seconds until there buddy can show up. That is all that is really going to happen.
I explain to them that it is not necessary to lay in the perfect Rear Naked Choke...but important that they can control and dominate there opponent enough to keep him from hurting him, and enough to escape or get assistance.
You don't have to be highly skilled to do these things. Just skilled enough to keep things in your favor..if the day is going somewhat your way.
I think we'd all really like to think that we can be like in the movies and do all that matrix stuff....but in reality...fighting is dirty, fast, and not much like how 99% of us train.
I can honestly say, I can produce an effective hand to hand fighter in about 30 to 60 days of solid training. That is about all that is really necessary to defend yourself and do what is necessary to win if things are meant to go your way.
everything else we do is simply to keep us in shape, entertain us, and maybe give us a slightly better edge...but the curve of diminishing return is very, very steep when you are talking self defense, survivability, and winning. Luck and situation play a bigger part than your overall training.
The only other reason to train is to keep your warrior spirit and the values of budo and to follow the DO.