AikiWeb Aikido Forums

AikiWeb Aikido Forums (http://www.aikiweb.com/forums/index.php)
-   General (http://www.aikiweb.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=1)
-   -   Aikido. Effective? (http://www.aikiweb.com/forums/showthread.php?t=14339)

mwible 04-22-2008 08:08 PM

Aikido. Effective?
 
I have been wondering lately, because i have seen everywhere (as I am sure many of you have too) people disclaiming Aikido and its effectiveness in combat, how many of you believe that you could use Aikido effectively in a real combat (life or death/ walk away or eat the pavement) situation?
Also, while I am asking this question, I would like to input that I whole heartedly believe that I could use what I have been taught in just such a situation.
And I don't care how long you have been studying, where you study, how you study, your rank… etc, I'm just looking for a straight up answer.
So.
Do you believe you could defend yourself using Aikido?

Domo,
Morgan

dps 04-22-2008 08:14 PM

Re: Aikido. Effective?
 
Quote:

Morgan Wible wrote: (Post 204199)
I have been wondering lately, because i have seen everywhere (as I am sure many of you have too) people disclaiming Aikido and its effectiveness in combat, how many of you believe that you could use Aikido effectively in a real combat (life or death/ walk away or eat the pavement) situation?
Also, while I am asking this question, I would like to input that I whole heartedly believe that I could use what I have been taught in just such a situation.
And I don't care how long you have been studying, where you study, how you study, your rank… etc, I'm just looking for a straight up answer.
So.
Do you believe you could defend yourself using Aikido?

Domo,
Morgan

Yes. I have done it once before.

David

mickeygelum 04-22-2008 09:03 PM

Re: Aikido. Effective?
 
Nicely phrased, yet you left out one criteria that would be crucial....in a physical or non-physical response. Without becoming more descriptive, I think that would round-out your query.

Forgive me, if this is incorrect.

Train well,

Mickey

mickeygelum 04-22-2008 09:17 PM

Re: Aikido. Effective?
 
Me again...:)

Yes, many times...professionally.

Twice the citizen, without a doubt to the benefit of the aggressor...not saying that they would not remember me, if they laid eyes on me again. They would not attempt an endeavor as they had previously. The select few that attained infamy by pushing the envelope...those folks , I would like to thank for the opportunity to further my ability to pass on knowledge of real-life experience to others.

Train well,

Mickey

MikeE 04-22-2008 09:40 PM

Re: Aikido. Effective?
 
Used it many times as a bar manager and for event security.

I do DT for LEOs and they love the application of aikido for their needs.

There are Tai Chi folks that can whoop some serious butt, and their are "mixed martial artists" that can't punch their way out of a wet paper bag.

IMHO, I think many times it comes down to the artist and not the art in question.

rob_liberti 04-22-2008 10:01 PM

Re: Aikido. Effective?
 
I recommend you read this thread:
http://www.aikiweb.com/forums/showth...007#post204007

Carl Thompson 04-22-2008 11:47 PM

Re: Aikido. Effective?
 
Hi Morgan,

I think you touched upon this in your 'Aikido the Martial Art' thread but "effectiveness" (however defined) is worth questioning again and again. I'd say you may well be able to use aikido effectively in the situation you described, or you could completely stuff it up and "eat the pavement". The likelihood of the former rather than the latter is subject to all kinds of factors, frequently discussed on this forum.

Quote:

Morgan Wible wrote: (Post 204199)
Do you believe you could defend yourself using Aikido?

Yes I could defend myself very effectively using aikido. I could also dramatically fail to defend myself using aikido.

Are there any arts in which this is not the case?

There are no easy answers, but I'd say that if you train to do something, the chances of actually being able to do it should increase if you're doing it right.

Carl

Kevin Leavitt 04-23-2008 12:12 AM

Re: Aikido. Effective?
 
As a soldier I have been trained using many different methodologies for combat and defense. Aikido being one of the methodologies that I still train in.

However, when asked the question concerning what I 'use', I use myself, body, mind, and whatever other tools are available, and/or appropriate for the job. I have never used a methodology such as aikido for anything else other than training myself.

Perspective, but I think we tend to attach ourselves too much to concepts and then identiffy with them. What it tends to do is constrain us, box us in, and cause questions such as "Does aikido really work?"

let go!

ChrisHein 04-23-2008 12:13 AM

Re: Aikido. Effective?
 
If trained correctly, you can't "use" Aikido, you become Aikido.

Stefan Stenudd 04-23-2008 03:13 AM

Avoiding attack
 
Quote:

Morgan Wible wrote: (Post 204199)
Do you believe you could defend yourself using Aikido?

Yes.
I also believe that many times, using aikido, I avoid being attacked at all.

SeiserL 04-23-2008 05:19 AM

Re: Aikido. Effective?
 
Quote:

Morgan Wible wrote: (Post 204199)
Do you believe you could defend yourself using Aikido?

Straight up? Yes.
Train with the intent and intensity so you can know the same about yourself.
IMHO, effectiveness is more about the person than the style.

DonMagee 04-23-2008 06:12 AM

Re: Aikido. Effective?
 
Most of the time I can't use aikido on a compliant uke. Maybe if I had 10 years of free time. But the training methods are slow in developing any aiki skills in me. This of course is compounded by the fact I no longer train aikido on any regular schedule.

Nah, I stick to my XD for self defense and leave the martial arts to the hobbys.

Stefan Stenudd 04-23-2008 08:01 AM

Aikido on aikido students
 
Quote:

Don Magee wrote: (Post 204225)
Most of the time I can't use aikido on a compliant uke.

It is more difficult to do aikido techniques on aikido students at keiko, even if they are somewhat compliant - because they know what to expect, so they can easily block it, even unintentionally.

When an aikido student really resists a technique, it can be very difficult to do it. That is no mystery, and it is the same for any martial art.
The ingredient of surprise is a necessary part of any technique, so a compliant uke sort of has to pretend to be surprised :)

Dewey 04-23-2008 08:12 AM

Re: Aikido. Effective?
 
Quote:

Don Magee wrote: (Post 204225)
Nah, I stick to my XD for self defense and leave the martial arts to the hobbys.

I agree with Don on this one. If this is just a "what if" sort of scenario, then the debate can be endless. Innumerable threads have been posted on this very same subject. The short of it is, nothing trumps a gun in regards to self-defense, provided you know how to use it and are aware of the legal & ethical ramifications of use-of-force.

There's a world of difference between "self-defense" and "combat"...and I'm presuming you mean self-defense. First, I think you need to properly assess what sort of situation/scenario you typically find yourself in when the concern about "self-defense" arises and then examine your motives and what the proper course of action should be (i.e. legal & ethical concerns).

If you are overly concerned about self-defense and fear for your life, then it would behoove you to legally acquire a concealable handgun (with the proper training & permits, of course). Even in feudal Japan, hand-to-hand was the "last resort" for the samurai when he found himself engaged in combat.

The real issue is having a self-defense mindset, being alert and aware of your surroundings at all times...keeping your guard up. Simply being observant of all that is going on around you and not intentionally placing yourself in dangerous/threatening situations (e.g. going to the "wrong side of town" and the like) are the single most effective means of self-defense.

The other issue is if you have a killer instinct or not. This not in the sense of actually killing, but rather in regards to if you are willing to fight. It doesn't matter what style/type martial art you study...what matters is if you have the ability to "flip the switch" and fight for your life when need be. Some folks just don't have it in them.

For what it's worth...

gregstec 04-23-2008 08:40 AM

Re: Aikido. Effective?
 
As long as you focus your Aikido training on learning the principles of Aikido, eventually you will be conditioned to use those principles when confronted with situations similar to those your learned the principles in.

In a combative situation you do not have time to think, you react. If conditioned with Aikido principles, your reactions will be Aikido movements.

Been in that situation a handful of times and that is exactly how it works, you just subconsciously react to the attack - when it is over, you are often amazed at what you did because there was no thought involved and things just happened.

Greg

charyuop 04-23-2008 08:44 AM

Re: Aikido. Effective?
 
Can I defend myself with Aikido??? huhhhh, don't know. Maybe if I am lucky and find the right person I might, or I might get my butt kicked from he to the North Pole. One thing is sure, Aikido is something I didn't have before, so I have a few more chances to get out with the least damage.

You asked about me and I answered about me, not being one of the best (actually light years away from it) Aikidoka. But yes I think someone proficient in this art can very well protect himself.

dps 04-23-2008 09:04 AM

Re: Aikido. Effective?
 
Maybe the answers to questions like this one should be divide into two categories.

1.) You can see the attack coming and have some time to prepare.

2.) You did not see the attack coming and you reacted from your training.

David

DonMagee 04-23-2008 09:20 AM

Re: Aikido. Effective?
 
I know what is going to happen when I'm surprised. Because I've had it happen.

I clinch, knee/elbow and throw. It's built into me at this point to automatically do this to break the guys balance so he can't hurt me. The funny part is I don't really train knees and elbows much, so I'm not sure where that part comes from, but basically I do dirty judo. The very few times this has happened it has ended up with me placing my 'attacker' in the knee on belly position before I even realize what's going on.

If I have time to prepare, I have time to leave or get help.

aikidoc 04-23-2008 12:13 PM

Re: Aikido. Effective?
 
I sure hope so. It's the only art I have any competence in. I hope I never need to find out.

mwible 04-23-2008 12:24 PM

Re: Aikido. Effective?
 
Quote:

Carl Thompson wrote: (Post 204209)
Hi Morgan,

I think you touched upon this in your 'Aikido the Martial Art' thread but "effectiveness" (however defined) is worth questioning again and again. I'd say you may well be able to use aikido effectively in the situation you described, or you could completely stuff it up and "eat the pavement". The likelihood of the former rather than the latter is subject to all kinds of factors, frequently discussed on this forum.

Yes I could defend myself very effectively using aikido. I could also dramatically fail to defend myself using aikido.

Are there any arts in which this is not the case?

There are no easy answers, but I'd say that if you train to do something, the chances of actually being able to do it should increase if you're doing it right.

Carl

I see what you are saying, good point. And i really liked the last paragraph of your reply :)

mwible 04-23-2008 12:25 PM

Re: Avoiding attack
 
Quote:

Stefan Stenudd wrote: (Post 204214)
Yes.
I also believe that many times, using aikido, I avoid being attacked at all.

I very much agree with this, and i feel the same way as well.

Aikibu 04-23-2008 12:26 PM

Re: Aikido. Effective?
 
I use Aikido everyday... That's how effective it is....

On a side note who wants to bet this thread grows to 15 pages? LOL.

WIlliam Hazen

mwible 04-23-2008 12:27 PM

Re: Aikido on aikido students
 
Quote:

Stefan Stenudd wrote: (Post 204229)
It is more difficult to do aikido techniques on aikido students at keiko, even if they are somewhat compliant - because they know what to expect, so they can easily block it, even unintentionally.

When an aikido student really resists a technique, it can be very difficult to do it. That is no mystery, and it is the same for any martial art.
The ingredient of surprise is a necessary part of any technique, so a compliant uke sort of has to pretend to be surprised :)

I also find it fun when i am uke and i REALLY AM surprised. haha. i love that feeling, and it lets you develop a better trust of your ukemi skills at the same time :P

Kevin Leavitt 04-23-2008 01:40 PM

Re: Aikido. Effective?
 
No William, I'd rather see the "other" thread rise from the grave! :)

Robert Cowham 04-23-2008 03:12 PM

Re: Aikido. Effective?
 
I have had a positive experience of it being effective for me (unexpected and indeed I was a little drunk at the time).

However I also remember as a youngster shooting birds (pigeon/pheasant) with a shotgun - I was a better shot when "surprised" and put gun to shoulder and shot immediately than when I saw the bird coming from a long way away and had time to line up (and anticipate it).


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:40 PM.

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.