AikiWeb Aikido Forums

AikiWeb Aikido Forums (http://www.aikiweb.com/forums/index.php)
-   Training (http://www.aikiweb.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=15)
-   -   "take the strength out of your shoulders." (http://www.aikiweb.com/forums/showthread.php?t=23640)

Riai Maori 05-26-2014 03:30 PM

"take the strength out of your shoulders."
 
"When you try taking the strength out of your shoulders, it often happens that your ki goes with it!"

Can someone please explain this sentence to me, I read on Aikido Journal?

http://members.aikidojournal.com/pub...ishiro-endo-1/

Thanks.:)

Janet Rosen 05-26-2014 04:52 PM

Re: "take the strength out of your shoulders."
 
If your structure is erroneously based on shoulders being up and out and strong, it follows that if you "take the strength out" without first improving your structure, it can unwittingly lead to a collapse of extension and intent.
How you define proper structure will vary based on who you study with. For example, those coming from Tohei Sensei lineage, focusing on the four principles, then exhaling and relaxing the shoulders, should do the trick. Others use different metaphors or ways to teach it.

NagaBaba 05-26-2014 07:51 PM

Re:
 
Quote:

Richard Campbell wrote: (Post 337243)
"When you try taking the strength out of your shoulders, it often happens that your ki goes with it!"

Can someone please explain this sentence to me, I read on Aikido Journal?

http://members.aikidojournal.com/pub...ishiro-endo-1/

Thanks.:)

Don't be mislead by someone from internet, ki don't exist. It is only urban legend...

AsimHanif 05-26-2014 08:39 PM

Re:
 
Richard,
sometimes when people relax their upper body they make the mistake of going limp or dead. Taking the strength out of your shoulders means to use only what you need, nothing more. For example, when you lift your arm, try using your lats and keep your delts (shoulders) soft. A lot of people will squeeze their delts to lift their arm. This is overuse.

dps 05-26-2014 08:55 PM

Re:
 
The secret to ki is that someone else is pulling the strings;

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=w-QQJ0E6SWA

dps

Cliff Judge 05-27-2014 08:27 AM

Re:
 
Quote:

Richard Campbell wrote: (Post 337243)
"When you try taking the strength out of your shoulders, it often happens that your ki goes with it!"

Can someone please explain this sentence to me, I read on Aikido Journal?

http://members.aikidojournal.com/pub...ishiro-endo-1/

Thanks.:)

Over-engaging the shoulder muscles during martial technique tends to prevent you from engaging other muscle groups, particularly those in the lower body.

It also prevents you from applying force into your opponent.

Tension in the arms is much easier for your uke to feel, allowing them to understand what you are trying to do and to counter it.

The concept of "ki" as I understand it breaks out into these three things. if you view the technique as a circulation of energy then using your shoulders too much serves to block or choke up that energy, meaning less power for the technique and more reaction on the part of uke. If you are afraid people are going to think you are a hippy for using eastern concepts in their proper context, then you can go spend a couple of years trying to figure out how to exactly model the whole thing with western kinesiology. But please shut up about it until you have a paper published in a respected journal. :)

jonreading 05-27-2014 09:01 AM

Re: "take the strength out of your shoulders."
 
I walk a tight rope here...

1. Ki is real, but it is concrete and reproducible. It is not to diminish muscular strength, but to identify a predecessor energy.
2. Eastern translations can be terrible. "Relax" rates for me as one of the most terrible translation/interpretation concepts in aikido.

For me, what Endo sensei is referring is using too much muscle recruitment in aikido. Excluding those muscles your body requires to fight gravity and maintain stability, generally we are talking about the overuse of muscular strength. The best analogy for this issue I have experienced in my rock climbing. When I first started rock climbing, I fatigued easily because I recruited more muscular strength than was needed to climb; mostly, this was the result of insecurity and fear related to my bodily safety. Later, as I better understood climbing and how my body worked, I was able to reduce this particular issue by recruiting less muscle.

What Endo sensei is talking about is not new - several other shihan spoke about this topic (Yamaguchi, Tohei, Sunadomari, Mochizuki, etc.). I am not convinced that instruction wasn't lost in translation, though. Essentially, it is not that we don't use power, it is rather the method of create that power that is of issue. We are working to convert our muscle power to another power source, namely ki. "Take strength out of your shoulder," is not synonymous with "do not have strength."

phitruong 05-27-2014 09:18 AM

Re:
 
Quote:

Richard Campbell wrote: (Post 337243)
"When you try taking the strength out of your shoulders, it often happens that your ki goes with it!"

Can someone please explain this sentence to me, I read on Aikido Journal?

http://members.aikidojournal.com/pub...ishiro-endo-1/

Thanks.:)

methink, this based on the asian's power sequence: power from below, control by the waist/hips (dantien really), express by the arms (including the shoulders). you can sort of equate that to the Tohei model: weight underside, keep one point, extend ki.

weight underside = power from below
keep one point = control by dantien
extend ki = express by the arms

at no point in those two models mentioned that power originated from shoulders. it's a jin or soft power model (whole body) vs hard power (pure muscular and localize). *note, me not wanting to get into the whole IS/IP/aiki war, because me are barbarians and don't care what other folks think, other than 'em make good targets for me axes*

try this article: http://members.aikidojournal.com/pub...y-mike-sigman/

Janet Rosen 05-27-2014 10:00 AM

Re:
 
Quote:

Phi Truong wrote: (Post 337255)
methink, this based on the asian's power sequence: power from below, control by the waist/hips (dantien really), express by the arms (including the shoulders). you can sort of equate that to the Tohei model: weight underside, keep one point, extend ki.

weight underside = power from below
keep one point = control by dantien
extend ki = express by the arms

at no point in those two models mentioned that power originated from shoulders. it's a jin or soft power model (whole body) vs hard power (pure muscular and localize). *note, me not wanting to get into the whole IS/IP/aiki war, because me are barbarians and don't care what other folks think, other than 'em make good targets for me axes*

try this article: http://members.aikidojournal.com/pub...y-mike-sigman/

Pretty much. I also relate "weight underside" to engaging the lats and extensors rather than the biceps and upper shoulders and "extend ki" as intent which includes not just express via arms but also eyes, dantien and energetically.

lbb 05-27-2014 10:15 AM

Re: "take the strength out of your shoulders."
 
There are a lot of "shoulder muscles"; for good aikido mechanics, the typical person needs to learn to use some of them less and others more. "Relax" is the opposite of "contract"; you cannot perform movement if everything is "relaxed". Again, mechanics: when dealing with the extremities, the mechanics are flexing and extension. A lot of aikido mechanics depend on extension, but whether you're flexing or extending, it's all being done by muscle contraction. Muscle relaxation doesn't make anything happen.

PeterR 05-27-2014 10:24 AM

Re:
 
Quote:

Jon Reading wrote: (Post 337254)
"Relax" rates for me as one of the most terrible translation/interpretation concepts in aikido.

How I hate that word. One of the great, overused, applied when you have nothing better to say, words ever.

dps 05-27-2014 05:01 PM

Re:
 
Quote:

Peter Rehse wrote: (Post 337259)
How I hate that word. One of the great, overused, applied when you have nothing better to say, words ever.

''Awesome''

dps

Walter Martindale 05-27-2014 08:50 PM

Re: "take the strength out of your shoulders."
 
Ki is real - I use it to lock and unlock my doors...

Tension. There's a difference between unconscious "relaxed" where the body flops and is very heavy, and "athletic" (for lack of a better word) "relaxed". In the latter, there's a "connectedness" between the top bits of the body and the bottom bits of the body, whether moving or not) and when you move the wrist of someone in this position, he/she will either stand his/her ground because you have got control, or he or she will fall on their gluteus maximus each evening. "not relaxed" tension? Unconscious, of course, you're dripping "stuff" all over the patio floor...

hughrbeyer 05-27-2014 09:02 PM

Re:
 
Quote:

Jon Reading wrote: (Post 337254)
"Relax" rates for me as one of the most terrible translation/interpretation concepts in aikido.

Quote:

Peter Rehse wrote: (Post 337259)
How I hate that word. One of the great, overused, applied when you have nothing better to say, words ever.

Maybe. But it's not just a translation issue. There's no better word in English I know of to express the body feeling you're going for if you're chasing this kind of power. Endo describes somewhere how he spent two years refusing to use any kind of power at all to learn to relax. Tohei said the only thing he learned from O-Sensei was how to relax. When people start to express just a little actual internal power, they commonly say, "But I didn't do anything."

Relax. Embrace the suck.

hughrbeyer 05-28-2014 07:31 AM

Re: "take the strength out of your shoulders."
 
I was mulling on this overnight, and I think it's our fault for misinterpreting the word "relax."

When does "relax" ever mean "go limp?" Ever ever ever? If you say to your kid who's keyed up about an exam, does that mean "lay back, don't try hard?" If a coach says to a gymnast before the big event "relax" does that mean "noodle your way through the routine?" If a baseball coach says to a batsman "relax" does that mean "swing the bat in a lackidaisical manner?" Why would we ever interpret "relax" in an Aikido context that way?

PeterR 05-28-2014 07:59 AM

Re:
 
Quote:

Hugh Beyer wrote: (Post 337299)
I was mulling on this overnight, and I think it's our fault for misinterpreting the word "relax."

When does "relax" ever mean "go limp?" Ever ever ever? If you say to your kid who's keyed up about an exam, does that mean "lay back, don't try hard?" If a coach says to a gymnast before the big event "relax" does that mean "noodle your way through the routine?" If a baseball coach says to a batsman "relax" does that mean "swing the bat in a lackidaisical manner?" Why would we ever interpret "relax" in an Aikido context that way?

Well to be fair - no one who ever used it for me meant "go limp". I would not have minded it so much if they did - I could understand that. It just seemed to me that those who used the term could have found some more tangible expression of what they wanted to get across. I suspect your baseball coach is also taking the lazy way out.

jonreading 05-28-2014 09:20 AM

Re:
 
Quote:

Hugh Beyer wrote: (Post 337299)
I was mulling on this overnight, and I think it's our fault for misinterpreting the word "relax."

When does "relax" ever mean "go limp?" Ever ever ever? If you say to your kid who's keyed up about an exam, does that mean "lay back, don't try hard?" If a coach says to a gymnast before the big event "relax" does that mean "noodle your way through the routine?" If a baseball coach says to a batsman "relax" does that mean "swing the bat in a lackidaisical manner?" Why would we ever interpret "relax" in an Aikido context that way?

This is part of the interpretation fault. It is our fault. To answer your question, at some point in time, we allowed an authority to use the term and we did not challenge the context or require an explanation of the message. We bowed our head and said, "thank you," then proceeded to keep doing something. Before us, that authority received the same instruction from a predecessor and so on back to the original use, which meant something.

The problem is that "relax" itself is not knowledge; the phrase is a mnemonic device used to recall an inherited knowledge. When I played baseball, I never relaxed. When fielding, I assumed the athletic position. When batting, I assumed the athletic position. The athletic position was the knowledge, "relax" was just the device that allowed me to recall what I was doing. Visit a little league, you'll notice coach doesn't use mnemonic devices yet because the kids haven't inherited the knowledge. You'll still hear, "bend your knees," Keep your bottom down," "keep up your head," and "keep your bat back." These are all components of the athletic position, but the instruction is more precise.

Ultimately, the pessimist in me says that aikido chooses not to define this term, nor hold people accountable for their use of the term. I have been ranting about the deliberate absence of success metrics in aikido for a while, no need to get back on that soapbox. Relax is an adequate word to describe the education of proper body usage. But, I bet if you started a thread you could not find a consensus on what, why and how.

"Relax" is aikido's version of "Smurf." There is more variation in the usage and meaning and context of that term that you can quantify.

Smurf into your stance
Smurf when you throw
Smurf when you receive
Smurf your breathing
The secret to kokyu dosa is smurfing
Smurf your shoulders
You need to smurf
It's not like smurfing into a La-z-boy
You're not smurfing enough

See? It works.

lbb 05-28-2014 09:40 AM

Re: "take the strength out of your shoulders."
 
When speaking of muscle mechanics, does not "relax" mean exactly that -- go limp?

I understand that that's not generally what people mean when they tell you to "relax", but then you ask "how" and they delve into a discussion of mechanics, and then they run into the problem that this is exactly what "relax" means. It's bad vocabulary to use "relax" when you mean something much more complex, as per Jon's example.

Phil Van Treese 05-28-2014 11:38 AM

Re:
 
"Don't be mislead by someone on internet...Ki don't exist. It is just urban legend"

I don't know where you learned martial arts, if you did, but ki does exist. You haven't fed your students with enough sardines yet to encourage them to learn. For you, sardines are the "ki" for them to learn.

phitruong 05-28-2014 12:31 PM

Re:
 
Quote:

Phil Van Treese wrote: (Post 337322)
I don't know where you learned martial arts, if you did, but ki does exist. You haven't fed your students with enough sardines yet to encourage them to learn. For you, sardines are the "ki" for them to learn.

whoa! hold on there! when did sardines the ki for aikido? i thought it was spam, not sardines. there was even a mention of vegetarian spam, but doesn't sound too good to my digestive system, since vegeterians are a bunch of ornery folks. :)

NagaBaba 05-28-2014 01:18 PM

Re:
 
Quote:

Phil Van Treese wrote: (Post 337322)

I don't know where you learned martial arts, if you did, but ki does exist. You haven't fed your students with enough sardines yet to encourage them to learn. For you, sardines are the "ki" for them to learn.

Now, when you mentioned sardines, I'm starting to think I could be deadly wrong...

Janet Rosen 05-28-2014 01:32 PM

Re:
 
Quote:

Szczepan Janczuk wrote: (Post 337328)
Now, when you mentioned sardines, I'm starting to think I could be deadly wrong...

Dunno, are you instructing SEALS? :D

jonreading 05-28-2014 01:52 PM

Re:
 
Quote:

Janet Rosen wrote: (Post 337331)
Dunno, are you instructing SEALS? :D

Janet, that should be a time out for you. Terrible.

Janet Rosen 05-28-2014 02:20 PM

Re:
 
Quote:

Jon Reading wrote: (Post 337334)
Janet, that should be a time out for you. Terrible.

Gee, I was proud of myself for the four second turnaround from reading to writing to posting....

Riai Maori 05-29-2014 02:34 AM

Re: "take the strength out of your shoulders."
 
Big thanks to everyone for the clarification. "When you try taking the strength out of your shoulders, it often happens that your Ki goes with it!" Often I am told to relax in the shoulders and couldn’t comprehend what was required from me. Any more relaxed and I would need to be asleep. Sensei mentioned last night at training, if you’re sweating, its either you’re unfit or you are over using muscles that don’t need to be worked hard. The latter applies to me. After Bokken training, my front and middle deltoids are pumped to the max. Does being muscle bound affect being relaxed (bad word)? I have been told from Japanese 7th Dan Aikido practitioners I have good Ki, I thought this means strength. Talk about confused!!! And for those who don’t know I am a 3 Kyu studying for 3 years.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:12 PM.

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.